Several States Using Little-Known Fund to Jump-Start the Clean Economy

Report finds that 22 states are tapping “CEFs” to build renewable energy projects. Some are going further by using the money to build entire industries.

A little-known source of clean energy funding could prove a crucial job-creation engine in the states, as federal support diminishes and they seek fresh growth drivers.

Every state can create clean energy funds, or CEFs, which are typically supported by a small surcharge on monthly electricity bills. So far 22 states have done so, generating $2.7 billion overall for the clean technology sector during the past decade. Most have used the money to install tens of thousands of solar panel arrays, wind turbines and biomass facilities.

But a few states have gone further by broadening investments to include technology research hubs, fledgling cleantech startups and green job training programs. The idea is to use the money, which today totals some $500 million a year, to help develop all the components of the clean economy and stimulate the creation of thousands of permanent local jobs.

The strategy is still experimental, but it could turn these CEFs into a major source of economic growth, according to new report published today by the Brookings Institution, a public policy group, and the Rockefeller Foundation, a philanthropic organization. The report outlines a four-part policy strategy for every state to adopt this “next generation” of CEF spending.

Clean Energy Funds were originally set up more than 10 years ago to help decarbonize state energy systems in the face of climate change. According to the report, the funds have already helped bring forward 72,000 renewable energy installations the country urgently needs.

But times have changed, said Mark Muro, a report co-author and director of policy for Brookings’ Metropolitan Policy Program. “Economic development has emerged as a parallel and complementary interest to carbon reduction … There’s been a sharpening concern that the country really needs to look to supporting the emergence of cutting-edge technologies” as a way to start new industries and create jobs, he told InsideClimate News.

According to the report, retooling these state-level funds “could not be timelier at this moment of federal gridlock and market uncertainty.”

Congress isn’t expected to approve new funding for green technologies in 2012 after the 2009 stimulus-which poured tens of billions of dollars into clean energy projects-dries up. And policymakers won’t likely reinstate key federal subsidies that lapsed at the end of 2011, including the Energy Department’s 1705 loan guarantee program, whose bankrolling of the now-bankrupt California solar firm Solyndra sparked a Republican-led effort to scale back President Obama’s green agenda.

“We all need to be thinking about where we are going to get policy and finance support for further economic development in clean energy,” Muro said. “As it happens, the clean energy funds are there and in a position to innovate.”

The Evolution of CEFs

The country’s first CEFs popped up in places with aggressive renewable energy goals, like California, Massachusetts and Rhode Island. Other states gradually followed suit, namely in the East Coast and Midwest.

They used the cash to get more solar panels on rooftops and wind turbines in the ground, which they hoped would help make renewable electricity as cheap as coal. Affordable clean power would have another benefit: it would unleash consumer demand for solar and wind, and spur new jobs in installation, manufacturing, among other areas.

But some states saw that the high cost of renewable power generation wasn’t the only obstacle to realizing the promise of the green economy. In order to build lasting cleantech industries, they’d have to subsidize research and development for new technologies, like advanced biofuels, electric vehicles and highly efficient solar panels, and eventually build a ready workforce and supply chain for manufacturing.

And so, starting a few years ago, a handful of states began experimenting with ways to transform their CEFs by linking the money to strengths in their economies.

For New York, that has meant sending some of its CEF money into its growing number of regional clusters, where high-tech companies, universities and research institutions that have similar industry focus share expertise. In 2009, the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA), which administers the state’s CEF and other clean energy programs, saw a chance for those regional clusters to help a rising crop of clean energy startups become viable companies.

The Clean Energy Business Incubator program has given $1.5 million from the CEF to each of six business incubators, which assist cleantech entrepreneurs in organizing, staffing and funding new businesses. Together, the incubators work with around 70 companies, whose products range from analytical tools that measure wind energy resources to energy management systems and mounting devices for solar photovoltatic installations. The money gets doled out over the course of four years as companies pass certain milestones, like completing a business plan or attracting private investments.

So far, participating companies have created several hundred new jobs, raised more than $40 million in private capital and attracted $11 million in federal funding, according to the Brookings-Rockefeller report.

“We have tremendous hopes for programs like the Clean Energy Business Incubator,” said Janet Joseph, vice president of technology and strategic planning at NYSERDA. “If these CEFs could be used to not just support [clean energy] resource acquisition, but also technology development and business development, I believe we would further accelerate the development of a clean energy industry.”

Massachusetts is also steering a chunk of its CEF dollars in this direction.

The state’s CEF was formed in 1997 mostly to finance renewable power installations and energy efficiency programs. The fund has since been absorbed by the Massachusetts Clean Energy Center, a development agency created four years ago out of Gov. Deval Patrick’s sweeping set of green economy policies.

The bulk of the roughly $22 million that the state gets from utility bill surcharges still goes toward that original mission. But the center is increasingly capitalizing on the state’s high number of research and academic institutions and strong venture capital community to drive clean economic growth in other sectors, said Kate Plourd, a spokesperson for the Clean Energy Center. (Paragraph includes correction added on 01/12/2012.)

We really try to take this holistic approach so we’re getting [economic] benefits from all sides,” Plourd said. The goal is to support “long-term economic growth for companies that will eventually create more jobs in Massachusetts.”

Its catalyst program, for example, awards up to $40,000 in grants to researchers working on early-stage technologies, such as high-performance lithium-ion batteries used for energy storage or a process that turns algae into motor fuel. A second program provides seed venture investments of up to $500,000 for companies that are advancing a range of renewable energy technologies and tools to cut energy use and climate-changing pollution.

In total, these two CEF-funded programs in Massachusetts-along with grants to help existing companies grow-have awarded more than $8 million in equity investments, loans and grants to companies since early 2009 and lured almost $300 million in additional funds. (Paragraph includes correction added on 01/12/2012.)

State officials say the strategy is paying off. Massachusetts now employs more than 64,000 people at nearly 5,000 clean energy companies, according to the Clean Energy Center’s October 2011 green jobs count. The number of clean economy jobs jumped 6.7 percent from July 2010 to July 2011. Companies surveyed in that report expect another increase of 15.2 percent this summer compared to last year.

No research has tracked how many jobs the CEFs alone have created in the states.

A Brookings report from July 2011 found that 2.7 million Americans work in the clean economy, which spans industries ranging from natural resources conservation and wastewater treatment to renewable energy deployment and energy-efficient construction.

What’s the Hold Up?

Why aren’t other states using their CEFs for economic development?

“For the most part, this is just a relatively new idea that really needs to be explained, and the benefits of it need to be shown, said Lewis Milford, who co-authored the report and is president of the Clean Energy Group, a Vermont-based advocacy organization.

Recently, Republican-led efforts have tried to dismantle state-level green energy initiatives, such as renewable energy standards, which require utilities to get a certain percentage of power from renewable sources. Opponents say if clean energy technologies are viable they should be able to thrive in the free market without government intervention.

But when it comes to CEFs, Milford said he wasn’t aware of such partisan spats.

In fact, he sees an increasing interest from state officials who are looking to both boost their economies in the lingering recession and cushion themselves from the loss of federal clean energy subsidies. “States are looking at their own competitive advantage and asking, ‘How do we grow what we have?’” he said.

Corrections: An earlier version of this article stated that the CEF in Massachusetts was formed in 1998 and that the state spends $22 million annually in CEF money. The fund was established in 1997 and the utility bill surcharge generates $22 million on average each year, with a bulk of that going into the CEF.

The article also stated that the state’s CEF programs gave more than $20 million to companies since early 2009 and lured $17 million in additional equity investments, loans and grants. The programs have actually awarded some $8 million in equity investments, loans and grants to companies since that time and lured almost $300 million in additional funds. These corrections have been made.

Source


44 Responses to “Several States Using Little-Known Fund to Jump-Start the Clean Economy”

  1. When someone writes an paragraph he/she maintains the image of a
    user in his/her brain that how a user can know it.
    So that’s why this piece of writing is perfect. Thanks!

  2. Hi there mates, its impressive article regarding educationand fully
    explained, keep it up all the time.

  3. Definitely imagine that that you stated. Your favourite reason seemed to be at the web the easiest
    factor to take into account of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed whilst other people think about concerns that they just
    don’t understand about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the highest and also outlined out the entire thing without having side-effects , other folks can take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thank you

  4. I do not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good.
    I don’t know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already ;) Cheers!

  5. I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.
    The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness over that you wish
    be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come
    more formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this hike.

  6. One minor drawback is that the radiator does get quite hot.
    I was surprised simply because I suspected the Amish
    built premium products. One minute you’re enjoying the hazy copper aura of Fall and then wham, it’s
    November.

  7. I used one of my shaving gels and first shaved under my arms.

    It’s black and silver casing is tough and durable if not a little cheap looking. Battery life long without doubt help to maintain if you travel from one place to another.

  8. I get committed a will Terminal, and you will get your money’s worth. As a citizen, it’s unmanageable owned and rock-steady
    Calgary commercial roofing company: Commercial
    Roofing bushel and Commercial Roof transposition Company in Calgary.

    Yeah, advantageously, subsequently they hitch her
    number, the commencement condom Roofing Company was installed entirely in
    1980 and it’s solely 29 days ago. Kevin ”The internet site Wizard” V. Dec 14, 2010, roof trucking rig-annually and afterward major storms it’s
    hard to recognize.

  9. Examples are : A Heartful of Love, Be Mine, Be My Valentine etc.
    Do you need mail order or do you prefer to see and touch your materials before purchasing.
    Here is how you can make your photo gift, your photo craft - SPECIAL.

  10. I believe this is one of the most significant information for me.
    And i’m satisfied studying your article. But wanna observation on some basic issues, The website style is great, the articles is truly nice : D. Good job, cheers

  11. Very good post! We are linking to this great post on our site.
    Keep up the great writing.

  12. This 5-quart model will help you make casseroles,
    soup, and roasts easily. That special graduate in
    your life will think of you every time they use that
    slow cooker in their college dorm. After you gain
    some experience, you can begin to improvise with chicken or beef broth, wine, tomato
    juice,etc.

  13. Hi! I know this is kinda off topic but I’d figured I’d
    ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest authoring a blog post or vice-versa?

    My website addresses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I
    believe we could greatly benefit from each other.
    If you are interested feel free to send me an e-mail.
    I look forward to hearing from you! Great blog by the way!

    my page; company of heroes 2 keygenerator cd key (Windy)

  14. Thanks for your marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you may be a
    great author. I will always bookmark your blog and will eventually come back in the
    foreseeable future. I want to encourage that you continue your great posts, have a nice weekend!

  15. I am sure this paragraph has touched all the internet people, its
    really really nice post on building up new webpage.

  16. 457635 832948If your real pals know you as your nickname, use that nickname as your 1st name online. When you 1st friend someone, focus on producing a private comment that weaves connection. 282762

  17. ” A sniffer intercepts information by spoofing a person’s IP address. Take Just use the secret to success to a phisher, which I think is incredibly simple. Already it can be being used by mining companies to file a lawsuit governments continuing to keep them from protected areas; by banks fighting financial regulation; with a nuclear company contesting Germany’s decision to change off atomic power.

    my blog: wifi password hack in urdu (Gay)

  18. good articles

  19. thank you for share!

  20. When I initially commented I appear to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are
    added- checkbox and from now on each time a comment is added I recieve four emails with the
    exact same comment. Is there a way you are able to remove me from that service?
    Many thanks!

    Here is my site: updated blog post - http://jamesarthur477.webs.com/,

  21. I am sure this article has touched all the internet viewers, its
    really really fastidious paragraph on building up new blog.

    My weblog … more about the author

  22. Thank you for some other informative website. Where
    else may I get that type of information written in such a
    perfect method? I have a challenge that I am simply now operating on, and I’ve been at the look
    out for such information.

    Look into my web site try these out (Sylvester)

  23. And Fb has gone within the last six months from being the very best to the
    worst.

  24. If you have something valuable on your own Facebook business page
    your enthusiasts should know about, it is possible to send them an update in order that they’re
    aware of it. End up being prudent with how usually you do that by only sending improvements to
    fans if it is really important.

  25. The variety of flash patterns varies depending upon the sort of light bars
    you opt for. When you are purchasing LED vehicle light, there are a number
    of things that you need to become particularly aware of.
    Rc led light bar The polycarbonate bases and UV inhibitor domes provide
    excellent encapsulation this keeps the LED
    lamps, moisture and corrosion resistant.

    A three years old phone that has been hailed by Sony Ericsson as among its best media
    phones of 2009, could it still stand tall in 2011.
    A mini lightbar what is the best light bar to buy after often a very affordable
    option in terms of emergency lighting in vehicles like cop cars, mini vans and medical ambulances.

  26. It is also aimed at enabling you to manage your Black - phytolacca berry tablets side effects files in a
    manner similar to those on your PC, along using the bonus of zipping and unzipping files.
    Ombu tree seeds So it required to consider precautions prior to the alarming situations.

    Although acai is boasted in some fat loss products, few areas of study have tested the advantage
    of acai juice in promoting weight reduction. You
    use a broad variety of suitable plants that you will find at a specialty bonsai garden center
    that may make a great indoor bonsai project.

  27. Affordable laptops are getting to be a new favourite amongst online
    searchers as they’re well equipped with the most recent technology and
    software. However, if you will want a gaming computer or one that may allow
    that you do some video editing, watch some movies, and focus the Internet the trouble goes up.
    Best gaming laptops 2012 under 1500 This gaming laptop
    also includes a Blu-ray burning drive, which most laptops don’t have.

    The disk drive and memory are pretty simple to upgrade, however, these are definitely much less important inside the gaming world since the processor,
    video and network cards. This presents a problem for laptop
    gamers because if they could’t start to see the images properly, they will’t play the
    overall game properly.

    ?The detail on many happening is usually known with all the help of improved media.
    Best 15 inch gaming laptop samsung series 7 gamer It is incredibly much
    essential to get a people in India to get well known concerning the political issues.

  28. Probably essentially the most excellent option on your vanishing points is on someplace
    where your image fits the guts spot of your respective paper.

    A good discount flower moby delivery company will that these are
    flowers are going to be sent for you fresh and vibrant.
    Flower video game If you wish your pictures to jump out, train your eye to appear for photo opportunities with contrast.

    Flower girls aren’t only the particular and cutest members with the bridal party, but they may also be the only
    other females which might be allowed to make use of white.

    When that you are sending thanks flowers in Sioux Falls,
    you may’t send just any form of floral designs.

  29. So move it, and rush towards the toy store to grab some
    Ben 10 toys Your kids will enjoy it and you will stay happy when you see them being engaged and learning
    interesting things with their toys. And many more by incorporating
    recurring from Toy Story 1 and two and some new ones being introduced
    inside Toy Story 3 adventures. Nerf upgrade springs Nowadays, there are too many
    kids toys with good quality and exquisite package in the toys
    market.

    These affordable F150 accessories like grilles, Nerf some bars, floor mats,
    tanneau covers, wheels, desh kits and bed grills are available at several retail stores of your respective Ford F150.
    In the late 1940’s a Brooklyn-based inventor named George Lerner started to attempt to license
    a toy concept he had developed.

  30. Folic acid is quite important to maintain hair follicle cell division and growth.

    On additional investigation of biotin and hair thinning, it had been found very clearly that folks
    who have type A blood can’t seem to absorb this kind
    of vitamin. biotin for hair regrowth and tablets
    for hair growth Remember diet and exercise are just one
    single weapon in the fight against thinning hair.

    But since Biotin just isn’t FDA-approved-you try Biotin your own risk.
    It isn’t that the body will extract the vitamins only from
    nice hair, but using their company areas at the same time, to
    meet the survival demand with the needed areas.

  31. The perfect skirt is quicker to find, as compared to a mother from the
    bride gowns or maybe a motherofthebridedresses. The first layer
    can be a softer, furry, warmer undercoat plus the second layer is done up in the longer, coarser
    hairs. Eggs Also many people which can be
    conscious about their own health prefer marinating and smoking their particular meat
    given it affords them the data of exactly what they can be
    consuming.

    These colonies of unfriendly bacteria could have flourished because from the
    types of food you take in or the insufficient good bacteria inside your body.

    Mix with two tablespoons of grape seed mayonnaise, or in case you don’t like mayonnaise, use two tablespoons or higher as needed of
    tahini sauce, produced from crushed sesame seed paste.

    ?However there isn’t any official training program
    or quiz to know the skills necessary for internet marketing.

    Does weed go bad beer They required the military
    that went to address the emus using machine guns
    but lost your dream by virtue of expenses of ammunition.

  32. This cause they are gaining huge popularity within the conventional wired surveillance security cameras for iphone.
    With this there is usually a function that when you’re typing a thing, it’s possibilities of their word pop-standing on screen for one to choose.
    It’s just that they can’re so common which they’ve become vehicles for crooks.

    Other factors to consider could well be bandwidth limitations (if any), and server location, that may affect where your IP address comes from.
    The greatest and simplest way to overcome the problem is by just running ethernet cables around your home to your points
    that you just want to attach.

  33. As instead of other lighting systems today,
    LED grow light products are economical. These are neon grow lights, metal halide (MH) grow lights, and also ruthless
    sodium (HPS) grow lights. Led grow lights for sale south africa This is one of the lights the ancients called chakras – invisible wheels of their time that heal body, mind,
    and spirit.

    Getting led lights installed is the top way to lower your expenses and green living to protect the planet earth and your own personal
    lives at the same time. Before growing basil in the home, think
    about the ambient room temperature.

    ?If that you are irresponsible or reckless while operating one of the machines, you may have your
    license revoked. T8 led grow lights review specifying Happier thoughts = happier biochemistry = Healthy body= Life of abundance.

  34. Adjust the directional antenna for the direction of the station or even the tower to progress reception. This could be
    the reason why these antennas are usually put on high gain hdtv antenna be ground where there is
    less obstruction for this way it can obtain the signal
    in the straight line. Best hdtv outdoor antenna Raising the height of one’s antenna just a little more can ensure good picture quality and
    sound.

    Check using your cable or satellite provider to find out what Hdtv receiver-tuner works
    with for receiving Hd broadcasts from them. And when it comes to social status, big
    HDTV’s serve realize that, yes world, you’ve arrived.

  35. Every year it would appear that there can be a hot new craze for
    the toy or gadget during Christmas time.
    Puppy toys like the heartbeat toy is beneficial to a puppy that
    is so nervous of the new environment. nerf n strike stampede ecs revolvers You will likely be lucky to
    possess these toys when you get the first pup to bring home.

    However, what’s a little weight compared on the
    fun and also the enjoyment that your little
    rascals will have if they have this toy. In addition for the suitable ages, the toys’
    quality is additionally important.

  36. Sources : Personal experience with the products The product labels.
    Because you are breaking down muscle tissue (via weight training), your metabolism needs to burn and use calories
    in order to rebuild that broken down muscle tissue. how many tablespoons is 100 grams of butter many
    cups is 85 grams of pasta

  37. What must be the vitamins and minerals present in vitamins for the head of hair.
    Patients who had poorly controlled diabetes received Cr (600 ug) plus biotin at Walmart (two mg) daily
    for 90 days. Biotin images A proper diet will help
    maintain your skin, nails and hair in good shape.

    Wolf berry really helps to eliminate toxins in the body in result of better function of the kidney, liver
    and blood which help to promote hair growth. Although it isn’t
    possible to change back the hands of time, you are able to learn the
    way to reverse gray hair naturally.

  38. Finish with the optional spritz of Bumble and Bumble Surf Spray and you also are done.
    If you understand everything regarding the all skin types and natural skin care tips e.
    Beauty tips kylie jenner As already stated earlier, cleansing might help in keep the skin fresh and clear of unwanted oil and debris.

    You’ll be very impressed by the amount of photos can be produced
    to “pop” by merely increasing the contrast some notches while tweaking the brightness
    to make certain your subject remains well-lit. You may
    also use refrigerate used tea bags over your
    swollen eyes.

    ?In general you’ll have to have around an hour to be able to prepare
    for regular work, plus one more hour to venture to work.
    otherwise (http://www.everytrail.com/profile.php?user_id=3666823) beauty tips
    and tricks without makeup In case your news release goes through,
    you are going to probably be able to realize the top page with the news on your selected keyword.

  39. The Digital Video clip Recorder may be the “”brain”" of the CCTV program; it will take the images in the cameras and stores them on into a hard disk drive. There are so many different brand, quality Car dvr in the market, as a customer may not easy to find a best one among so many different dash Q See Camera
    Software Right
    . Best small business security camera system This makes a DVR easy to maintain because there are no bulky tapes to change or
    the probability of losing video quality when recording over previous
    footage.

    The presence of CCTV as integrated security solutions
    can also be important for that work ethic and efficiency
    of employees. Though marriage counseling professionals might
    frown because they begin to lose business, Direc - TV DVR by Tivo could prove to be the
    very best thing marriage has ever seen.

  40. This is accomplished by allowing the leaves with the plant to die.
    Artificially tinted(2) orange callas (50 flowers cost $159) brighten the orange tones considerably without overpowering the blooms’ interior yellow.
    You would be wise to go local before outsourcing to long distance companies.

    Therefore, you cannot really customize a legal contract with certain flowers or
    colors. FTD’s on-line flower delivery customer service region is detailed.

    ?However, to use simplest form, politics is the procedure through which power is acquired and maintained, and collective decisions are created by a band of people.
    Calla lily planting calla lily in water s
    jewelry that included her engagement ring for the hijackers.

  41. And having a detailed video of the crime, police officers will offer an easy time
    solving it. Critics of facial recognition technology site the
    potentiality for mass surveillance and also the further
    loss in civil liberties. Security World cameras at best buy Most people
    recognize that installing a burglar alarm camera system may help protect
    their houses and businesses, but may not possess the budget to allow them to fit a complete system.

    Some places could possibly be very high from the ground or perhaps very distant from where you
    are going to be monitoring. While it’s going to not send back video like real cameras,
    they could be equally effective in deterring intruders.

  42. Make sure they allow that you search by occasion, search by price and appearance by flower.
    Well, it will not be that difficult, firstly, you need to produce sure that this website in the online florist is an easy task to use and understand.
    Flower factory If the flower here is backlit,
    you are able to avoid lens flare by a broad brim hat or by employing a lens shade to bar light from
    entering the lens.

    You can offer flowers delivered Bangalore anywhere within the country for virtually any occasion that it
    is possible to think of and it’s actually really quite simple to do.
    Our work combines modern flare with divine style to
    generate images that the clients will appreciate for several years.

  43. Here can be a couple tips that you should follow when trying
    to find that perfect ergonomic mouse for you.

    This game looks amazing for a Facebook game and celebrate good use
    in the Unity game engine. Best mouse for game So this bit of
    hardware enables laptop computer to send your control instructions towards the game.

    Here can be a run down of some with the best Gaming mouse Pad gaming mice available today.
    It is incredibly useful for gamers in addition to others who would like room to freely move their mouse.

  44. The inclusion in the invocation of both a Western (Indo-European) language and an Eastern language signifies the universality
    of this teaching. “Turn not to those [mediums] who have familiar spirits or to wizards; do not seek them out to be defiled by them. What does tbt meab

    Felidae is broken down into two groups or genera;?? Pantherinae and Felinae. If you are fortunate, the problem can be resolved by simply reseating the memory cards.

    ?So it really is important to make what is this great headline attractive so that this people continue reading what is the news article. c t f u what is hmu mean Huge quantity of people has started to
    invest within the share markets as opposed to depositing inside the
    banks, probably these are hoping for great returns.

Leave a Reply

You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

ss_blog_claim=09f600f8621dcbdcc85df20ccc1d59ab